Fortune's Shawn Tully argues that a proposed SpaceX-Tesla merger would be extremely dilutive for SpaceX shareholders, since SpaceX's GAAP profit per share would barely rise even as its bottom line grows while Tesla's drops. With Tesla's market cap at $1.52 trillion and a 30% acquisition premium, the deal would value Tesla at $1.98 trillion, against SpaceX's $2.14 trillion valuation, making it almost a merger of equals. SpaceX would need to issue shares equal to 92% of its outstanding stock, raising its share count from 13.1 billion to 25 billion and giving Tesla's sellers nearly half of its future earnings, while Tesla booked just $3.28 billion in GAAP net profit over the past four quarters. The newsletter also reports a worldwide market selloff as tensions with Iran looms, with Nasdaq futures down 1.82%.
Summary written by Upside AI from the original article. Read the source for full details.
Read the original on fortune.com ↗
Keywords
TSLAmergers and acquisitionsSpaceXvaluation
Open a keyword to see other news on the same topic.
Related tickers and likely impact
TSLA
▼ Likely negativeTesla, Inc.
Relevance: low
| Market | US stocks |
|---|---|
| Sector | Consumer Discretionary |
| Industry | Automobile Manufacturers |
| Market cap | $1.4T |
| Close on 10/21/2026 | 386.47 |
| Change that session | +3.41% |
Impact is scored by AI from the headline and may be wrong. It is not investment advice.
Related news
- Cold Water: Tesla and SpaceX Merger “Won’t Add Much Value” per Gary Black
Gary Black, managing partner of The Future Fund, argues that an all-stock Tesla–SpaceX deal at about $420 per Tesla share, roughly 10% above the current price, would add little value. Tesla trades at 191.6x forward earnings, well above its three-year average of 135.1x and above SpaceX's multiple, so the combined company would likely be valued at SpaceX's lower level. Tesla's normalized EPS fell from $3.12 in fiscal 2023 to $1.66 in fiscal 2025, with analysts expecting $2.17 in fiscal 2027. Musk said special committees at both companies are studying the idea and that he thinks it would be a good idea, but no terms have been agreed.
- Musk backs SpaceX-Tesla merger idea as both boards form special committees
Musk said on SpaceX's third-quarter earnings call that he thinks a SpaceX-Tesla merger would be a good idea, and that both companies have formed special committees of independent directors at shareholders' request. He cannot join those talks as a conflicted party, and he stressed a merger is not a certainty. Barclays analyst Dan Levy said a tie-up has become the consensus expectation, and that Tesla's annual meeting, which must be held by Dec. 6, is the appropriate venue for a shareholder vote, though a delayed announcement could push a deal out 6 to 12 months. At values of about $2.1 trillion for SpaceX and $1.5 trillion for Tesla, Levy estimated Musk would own about 37% of the combined company and 56% of its vote, and each Tesla share would be worth about 0.7 SpaceX shares before any premium.
- Musk's wants to merge SpaceX and Tesla: Here's what to know
Musk said SpaceX and Tesla have formed special committees to study a merger, which would be worth about $3.5 trillion combined and would be the largest corporate deal in history. SpaceX, valued at about $2 trillion after a record listing this year, absorbed Musk's AI startup xAI in February, while Tesla is valued at about $1.5 trillion. Musk holds about 82 percent of SpaceX's voting power but only about 20 percent at Tesla. Dan Ives puts the odds of a deal at 90 percent by early 2027, though Musk called the requirement of a majority of all Tesla shares 'quite a high hurdle'. Loyal retail investors hold an estimated 25 to 27 percent of Tesla shares, and legal obstacles appear slight because both companies moved their incorporation to Texas from Delaware.
- CLSA Says SpaceX Merger Buzz Overshadows Tesla's Concerns, But Musk's Public Endorsement Could Reportedly Complicate Deal Talks
According to Reuters, investors are increasingly optimistic about a possible merger of Tesla (TSLA) and SpaceX (SPCX), but Elon Musk's recent public endorsement reportedly worries some insiders, as it could draw shareholder scrutiny and delay the process by several weeks. CLSA upgraded Tesla to 'Hold' from 'Underperform' and raised its price target to $400 from $310, arguing that merger prospects outweigh its longer-term concerns. Musk confirmed both companies have formed special committees of independent directors to explore the idea, but said a deal is far from certain and that he cannot take part directly in negotiations. At the time of writing, SPCX shares were down 8% and TSLA shares were down 1.3%; the article also flags risks such as valuation, regulatory scrutiny and Tesla's operations in China.
- Could a Tesla-SpaceX merger really be the next big move for Elon Musk?
Two speakers discuss a possible Tesla-SpaceX merger and the outlook for Tesla stock. Speaker A argues that SpaceX, which he calls a vertically integrated AI company, would make a powerful combination, and says he will keep focusing on Tesla's Megapack business, which is sold out in utility-grade battery storage, as well as Optimus. He says he bought in at about $100 a share three years ago and sees volatility as a friend given his long-term perspective. Speaker B views Tesla's recent results as mixed to negative, with profit down over 40%, flat revenue, and better free cash flow mainly because capital spending was cut. He says Tesla is behind Waymo in autonomous driving (800 versus 8,000) and behind China in humanoid robots, and suggests a merger could be interesting and might benefit Tesla shareholders.
- Tesla held onto its bitcoin in Q3 as speculation of SpaceX merger grows
Tesla did not sell any of its Bitcoin in the third quarter, and its crypto holdings rose 42% to 962 million. The after-tax gain of 224 million, about 28.5% of the quarter's profit, came against net income of 787 million. Tesla holds 11,509 Bitcoin and SpaceX holds 18,712; the presenter notes that a merger would combine 30,221 Bitcoin and rank sixth among public companies by Bitcoin holdings. The two companies have now formed a special committee for the merger.
Related markets
Latest news
- Bank Profits Surge
The 9-month 2026 results show many banks continued to grow profits, with some posting record quarterly earnings. VPBank's pre-tax profit reached nearly VND 30,000 billion, up nearly 47%, equal to its full-year 2025 result and about 72.4% of its 2026 plan; Q3 pre-tax profit topped VND 11,000 billion. Techcombank posted VND 28,900 billion (up 23.7%), while LPBank reported VND 10,421 billion (up nearly 9%). SSI forecasts pre-tax profit of its monitored banks to rise 19.5% in 2026 before slowing to 15.4% in 2027, pressured by narrowing net interest margins and rising credit risk provisions. It also expects system-wide credit growth of 16-17% in 2027 and 17.9% for the monitored banks.
- World's Largest Gold Fund Dumps Over 10 Tonnes of Gold as Prices Slide
SPDR Gold Trust, the world's largest gold fund, continued net selling of nearly 12 tonnes of gold in the 22/10 session, bringing total sales over 2 sessions to nearly 15 tonnes and cutting its holdings to about 1,046 tonnes. Spot gold fell more than 2.8% to around USD 4,025 per ounce at the close of 22/10, and briefly dipped below USD 4,000 per ounce in the morning session of 23/10. Tensions in the Middle East pushed crude oil prices higher, raising concerns about inflation and further Fed tightening, and gold has still not attracted sustained safe-haven demand even as US Treasury yields fell. US September CPI rose 0.6% month on month and 3.7% year on year, while PPI rose 1.3% and 6.3%. Markets price about an 84% chance the Fed holds rates steady at its 27-28/10 meeting and a 16% chance of a 25 basis-point increase; September PCE data due on 29/10 is the next key factor to watch.
- Gold Prices Continue to Fall
On the morning of 23/10, domestic gold prices kept falling, with SJC bar prices varying by seller and the premium over world gold widening. Công ty TNHH Vàng bạc đá quý Sài Gòn listed SJC bars at VND 139-142 million per tael (buy-sell), down VND 300,000; Phú Quý was at VND 138-141.8 million, down VND 500,000; and Mi Hồng at VND 140-141.5 million, down VND 800,000. Gold rings also fell by varying amounts, with DOJI at VND 138-142 million and Phú Quý at VND 138-141 million per tael. World gold dropped USD 129 to around USD 3,992 per ounce, equal to about VND 125.3 million per tael, leaving SJC bars about VND 16.7 million per tael above the world price. The State Bank's central rate was set at 25,627 VND/USD, down 5 dong, while Vietcombank quoted 25,660-26,040 VND/USD (buy-sell).
- Company Linked to Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong Announces Major Good News
VEFAC (ticker VEF), a Vingroup subsidiary, posted Q3 net revenue of nearly VND 77 billion, up 67% year on year, but a gross loss of about VND 27 billion as cost of sales from its exhibition business exceeded revenue. Q3 profit rose mainly thanks to a gross gain of about VND 65 billion from transferring some schools in a project to a partner, while financial income reached over VND 388 billion, mostly from loan and investment income. For the first nine months of 2026, after-tax profit was nearly VND 865 billion, down about 94% from VND 15,418 billion in the same period of 2025, as the prior year included large gains from transferring part of the Vinhomes Global Gate project. As of 30/9/2026, total assets stood at over VND 31,905 billion, up 36% from the start of the year, while total liabilities exceeded VND 24,364 billion, with short-term customer advances rising from VND 411 billion to over VND 8,373 billion.
- Lotte and Phat Dat Officially Break Ground on VND 60,000 Billion Mega Project in Thu Thiem 'Golden Land'
A joint venture between Lotte Group (South Korea) and Phát Đạt (HoSE: PDR) officially broke ground on 23/10 on Lotte Eco Smart City Thu Thiem in the Thu Thiem New Urban Area, HCMC, with total investment of about VND 60,000 billion. The project covers nearly 7.5 ha and will combine Grade A offices, retail, services, accommodation and housing, adjoining the central plaza and central lake of Thu Thiem. Phát Đạt holds 35% of Lotte Properties HCMC, the project developer, and will develop the housing blocks along with two towers (2-1 and 2-3) with about 219,722 m2 of floor area, while Lotte handles block 2-5. Lotte Properties HCMC paid VND 17,569 billion in land-use fees on 31/7/2026, and Phát Đạt completed its VND 7,666 billion payment to take its 35% stake. MB is funding all of Phát Đạt's capital contribution, while VietinBank and BIDV also support the project.
- International Business : Global stocks nosedive as Meta dents AI optimism
Global stocks retreated as tech earnings failed to ease concerns about the AI outlook, with MSCI's All-World index set for its largest daily fall in two weeks, down 0.4 per cent. Meta beat third-quarter revenue expectations, but its plan to issue non-voting stock revived worries about its mounting capital commitments, and a New Mexico judge ordered it to pay a $25 billion penalty in a data privacy case. Brent crude rose nearly 3% to $112 a barrel, near a five-month high, after more Houthi attacks in Saudi Arabia raised supply risks. Investors moved into government bonds, pushing the US 10-year yield down to 5.05%, below France's for the first time in 13 years, while French yields have climbed above 5% amid concerns over social unrest and debt. The France-Germany 10-year spread reached 177.7 basis points, its widest since 2011, while gold fell 1.8% to $4,070 an ounce.
Get the briefing on Telegram or Zalo
Join the Upside Telegram channel or Zalo group for the Vietnam stocks and gold briefing at 8:00 and 19:00 (Vietnam time) on trading days, plus a weekly wrap on Saturday morning.