Gary Black, managing partner of The Future Fund, says that in an all-stock SpaceX–Tesla deal, merger arbitrageurs would push down SpaceX's price and shrink the 20-25% premium he expects for Tesla holders. He cites Marvell's all-stock offer for Lumentum, where a 24% premium on paper became a 16% discount to Lumentum's pre-leak price as Marvell's shares fell 32% from the October 28 close. Tesla trades at 189x forward earnings, above its three-year average of 137x, leaving little cushion if the premium comes in smaller than bulls hope. The article notes no deal terms exist yet, and the special committees' first terms will show the starting premium.
Summary written by Upside AI from the original article. Read the source for full details.
Read the original on Yahoo Finance ↗
Keywords
TSLASpaceXmergers and acquisitionsvaluationElon Musk
Open a keyword to see other news on the same topic.
Related tickers and likely impact
TSLA
▼ Likely negativeTesla, Inc.
Relevance: medium
| Market | US stocks |
|---|---|
| Sector | Consumer Discretionary |
| Industry | Automobile Manufacturers |
| Market cap | $1.6T |
| Close on 11/03/2026 | 398.22 |
| Change that session | -1.39% |
Impact is scored by AI from the headline and may be wrong. It is not investment advice.
Related news
- Barclays Says a SpaceX Merger Is Now "a Key Part" of the Tesla Bull Case. Here's Who Actually Wins if It Happens -- and Who Pays.
On Space Exploration Technologies' (SPCX) third-quarter conference call, CEO Elon Musk said he thought a merger with Tesla was a good idea, and the two companies have each formed a special committee to explore a combination. Barclays says such a deal would likely be funded largely or entirely through stock, and Tesla shareholders could benefit given SpaceX's market capitalization of roughly $2 trillion compared with roughly $1.55 trillion for Tesla. Barclays upgraded Tesla from equal weight to overweight and raised its one-year price target from $370 to $450 per share, a level that matches its expected all-stock buyout value, a premium of roughly 20% over the current price, or about 3.1 SpaceX shares per Tesla share. The deal would need a 50% affirmative vote from Tesla shareholders, with investors who do not vote counted as "no" votes, and Musk controls about 20% of voting power but would still likely need meaningful retail investor support. The article also notes that heavy dilution from new SpaceX share issuance to fund a deal makes the post-deal outlook for SpaceX stock harder to predict.
- Tesla-SpaceX Merger 'Does Make Strategic Sense,' Analyst Says — But SpaceX Needs Nearly 2x The Growth
Morningstar says a Tesla-SpaceX merger 'does make strategic sense,' but SpaceX would need growth nearly double what the firm currently models to justify its share price. Morningstar raised its SpaceX fair value estimate to $70 from $62, yet that still implies about 51% downside from current levels, even though its forecasts already assume revenue of $41 billion in 2026 and $228 billion by 2030. The Terafab chip project could cost tens of billions of dollars through early 2028 and more than $100 billion longer term, but the funding split between the two companies remains unresolved. Musk said his conflicts keep him out of the independent committees' talks and warned against treating a deal as certain.
- Tesla-SpaceX Merger Needs No Premium, Investor Says — But Floats $500 To Sway Angry Holders Missing Bigger Payoff
Larry Goldberg of LumaSenti says Tesla shareholders do not need a premium to benefit from a SpaceX merger, but floats $500 a share as a figure that could persuade reluctant investors, and says his priority is completing the deal. He argues that the lower the premium, the higher the value of the SpaceX stock received, and that combining assets and cash flows could help finance a computing buildout he estimates at $500 billion to $1 trillion. Brad Gerstner of Altimeter Capital suggests a $420 to $550 range, while ARK's modeling projects benefits for both shareholder groups from a no-premium swap. Tesla's quarterly filing confirms a special committee is exploring a deeper relationship with SpaceX; Musk says the committees have not agreed on terms and Tesla would need approval from 50% of all shares.
- Musk Calls Tesla’s Merger Vote “Quite a High Hurdle.” JPMorgan’s Premium Math Puts the Stock Near $500.
Elon Musk said on SpaceX’s October 20 earnings call that a SpaceX-Tesla merger would need the approval of 50% of all Tesla shares, not just votes cast, and that the two companies’ special committees have not agreed on terms. JPMorgan expects an all-stock deal led by SpaceX at a typical 30% to 35% premium, or about $486 to $505 a share versus Tesla’s $373.71 close. Turnout was about 74% at Tesla’s 2025 annual meeting, so a deal would need roughly two-thirds of votes cast, and a new auto-vote program for retail holders could help but has no public enrollment figures. The article notes that a 30% to 35% premium would push Tesla’s 191.6x forward earnings multiple to about 250x, versus a five-year average of 107.7x. Musk also said there is no guarantee the committees will reach a deal.
- Why a Merger With Tesla Could Be a Disaster for SpaceX
The article argues that a merger between Elon Musk's SpaceX and Tesla could be unfavorable for SpaceX investors. Both boards have formed special committees to review the deal, and Musk has recused himself while calling a combination “a good idea.” In the third quarter, SpaceX revenue more than doubled on growth in its AI infrastructure business, while Tesla revenue was flat at $28 billion, automotive revenue fell 3% to $20.5 billion, and vehicle deliveries dropped 2% to 486,532. The author says Tesla's valuation rests almost entirely on future products such as Optimus and self-driving, so SpaceX investors could overpay in a merger, and concludes they should oppose it until Tesla's valuation falls or its autonomy businesses show a clear financial impact.
- Cold Water: Tesla and SpaceX Merger “Won’t Add Much Value” per Gary Black
Gary Black, managing partner of The Future Fund, argues that an all-stock Tesla–SpaceX deal at about $420 per Tesla share, roughly 10% above the current price, would add little value. Tesla trades at 191.6x forward earnings, well above its three-year average of 135.1x and above SpaceX's multiple, so the combined company would likely be valued at SpaceX's lower level. Tesla's normalized EPS fell from $3.12 in fiscal 2023 to $1.66 in fiscal 2025, with analysts expecting $2.17 in fiscal 2027. Musk said special committees at both companies are studying the idea and that he thinks it would be a good idea, but no terms have been agreed.
Related markets
Latest news
- USDC Issuer Circle Quietly Cuts 5% of Staff in Profitable Quarter
Circle, the issuer of the USDC stablecoin, cut about 5% of its workforce to better align its organization with its operating model and strategic priorities, according to its Q3 results. It booked $9.1 million in restructuring charges, mostly severance and notice-period payments, even as net income from continuing operations rose 5% to $226 million. Much of the growth came from outside its core business, including $182 million from the presale of ARC tokens, while reserve income fell 8% to $658 million as reserve interest rates declined. The article notes Circle is one of several crypto firms, including Coinbase, BitGo and the Ethereum Foundation, that have cut staff this year.
- Nvidia Took Back the World’s Biggest Company Title From Apple on Election Day
Nvidia rose 2.29% to $206.69 on Tuesday, giving it a market value of $4.99 trillion and returning it to the top spot ahead of Apple, which fell 1.90% to $331.90 for a $4.84 trillion valuation. Nvidia’s lead is about $149 billion, well ahead of Microsoft at $3.87 trillion and Alphabet at $3.44 trillion. The article links rising AI-driven memory prices to Apple’s margins, which Apple guided to 45% to 46% for the December quarter, versus 47.9% in the quarter just reported, with roughly one point of that quarter’s margin from tariff refunds that will not recur. Nvidia guided fiscal third-quarter revenue to $108 billion, plus or minus 2%, and reports on November 17.
- Electric Vehicles Today - European Connector Market Driven By EV Adoption And Innovation
A research report summarized by Simply Wall St projects the European wire-to-board EV connectors market could reach about $1.3 billion by 2031, driven by rising EV adoption and European climate targets. Key segments benefiting include battery management and advanced driver-assistance systems, while Germany, France and the UK are cited as leading the rise in battery electric vehicle registrations. In the market update, EcoPro BM rose 11% to ₩97,200, Sumitomo Electric Industries fell 7.2% to ¥1,542, and Tesla settled at $398.50, down 1.3%.
- Silver price today, Wednesday, November 4, 2026: Silver prices shift as investors weigh the impact of a Democratic sweep
Silver December futures opened at $49.83 per ounce on November 4, 2026, up 0.2% from Tuesday’s open, and traded at $51.82 by 7:26 a.m. ET after Democrats swept the midterm elections and the dollar weakened. The gains were expected to be limited as investors weighed the economic impact of the shift of power on Capitol Hill. Silver was down 7.6% over one week and 19% over one month, but up 6.2% year-on-year. Hussain said the Fed was likely to stay hawkish given inflation, and because gold has become positively correlated with equities, continued weakness in tech stocks could also weigh on gold prices.
- Viking Therapeutics Trades 23% Below Its Own $35 Secondary Offering Price. Here's Why That Could Be a Gift for Patient Investors.
Viking Therapeutics (VKTX) has not yet commercialized any product, but its lead candidate VK2735 is in two phase 3 trials, one injectable and one oral. Analysts predict the weight loss drug market could approach $100 billion by the end of this decade, a space currently led by Eli Lilly and Novo Nordisk. Last month, Viking completed a secondary offering of common stock and convertible senior notes that raised $575 million to fund VK2735's phase 3 development, priced at $35 per share. The stock fell after the offering amid concerns over dilution and a 16% discount to the prior day's close, and now trades about 23% below $35, under $30. The author considers the current price reasonable given the company's pipeline progress, and notes that clinical trial updates could drive the stock.
- Is Google's New Cryptocurrency Service a Reason to Buy Ethereum or Solana?
Alphabet announced on October 28 its Google Multi-Party Compute (MPC) crypto security platform, with commercial launch scheduled for early 2027, and already uses it to secure its own digital assets on Ethereum and Solana. The platform splits a wallet's private key into fragments held on separate systems and checks each transaction against an institution's rules, supporting ECDSA and Ed25519 signing. The author argues the benefit to Ethereum and Solana is minor, since safer custody does not itself create demand, and notes Ethereum ETFs saw $635 million in net outflows and Solana ETFs $24.8 million in the first seven trading days of October 2026. The article says the signals to watch in the first half of 2027 are ETF flows and bank announcements naming Google's service.
Get the briefing on Telegram or Zalo
Join the Upside Telegram channel or Zalo group for the Vietnam stocks and gold briefing at 8:00 and 19:00 (Vietnam time) on trading days, plus a weekly wrap on Saturday morning.